Quick checklist
- Save the complete audit packet and all correspondence — notice, submitted records, and any outcome letter.
- Read any result notice, safety rating, or follow-up request carefully and note the response deadline.
- List each finding or corrective action item with the specific record category it involves.
- Assign a named owner and due date for every corrective action before the closeout meeting ends.
- Contact the reviewing office through official channels if you believe a finding or data point is incorrect.
- Schedule a 30-day follow-up to confirm corrective actions are closed and vendor-dependent items were received.
- Update the internal review schedule to add any record categories that were difficult to retrieve.
Why this matters
The week after an audit is when corrections either become part of the routine or disappear. Most carriers close out the obvious file fixes quickly — the ones that stick are those that also changed the process that caused the gap. It is also the point when the carrier needs to understand the formal outcome: whether a safety rating was issued, whether a corrective action response is required, and what the timeline looks like. Handling the administrative follow-up late costs more than handling it the same week.
What to prepare
| Area | Records to gather |
|---|---|
| Closeout folder |
|
| Possible follow-up actions |
|
| Process updates |
|
Common gaps
- Corrective actions have no named owner and are left in a general follow-up email.
- The carrier fixes the specific file that was flagged but not the process that allowed the gap.
- The result letter or safety rating notice is not saved with the audit packet.
- All audit correspondence is in one employee inbox with no backup or archive.
- Vendor-dependent corrective actions have no confirmation step — the carrier assumes the TPA or ELD provider handled it.
Before / During / After audit
Before
- Keep a blank closeout folder ready before the audit starts so it can be filled in during the review.
During
- Record every follow-up request exactly as the examiner phrases it.
- Confirm where the final outcome notification or instructions will be sent before the session ends.
After
- Hold a short closeout meeting within the first week to assign all corrective actions.
- Review any safety rating, outcome notice, or follow-up request with a safety consultant or attorney if the implications are unclear.
- Update internal review templates and recurring calendar reminders.
- Save documented proof of each completed corrective action with the audit packet.
FAQ
What is a safety rating and when does a carrier receive one after an audit?
A safety rating under 49 CFR Part 385 is the result of a compliance review, not a new entrant safety audit. The three possible ratings are Satisfactory, Conditional, and Unsatisfactory. Not every audit results in a formal safety rating — new entrant safety audits do not produce a safety rating. When a rating is proposed after a compliance review, the carrier receives a notice and has the opportunity to submit corrective actions before the rating becomes final.
Can a carrier dispute a finding or data point after a compliance review?
Carriers have two separate paths depending on what they are challenging. An administrative review under 49 CFR 385.15 is for situations where the carrier believes the finding was based on incorrect data or an improper application of the regulations. Submitting corrective action evidence under 49 CFR 385.17 is for requesting a rating upgrade without disputing the finding — the carrier accepts the record gap and demonstrates it has been corrected. The outcome notice identifies the FMCSA contact and should specify which process applies to the carrier's situation.
How long should audit records and correspondence be kept?
There is no single federal regulation that specifies how long audit records must be retained as a category. The underlying records have their own retention requirements under Part 391, Part 396, Part 395, and Part 382. As a practical matter, keeping the full audit packet — including the notice, submitted documents, outcome letter, and corrective action tracker — for at least three to five years gives the carrier reference material at any subsequent review.
Download
Use the print button to create a paper or PDF copy from your browser. No account or upload is needed.
Sources
FMCSA · official
Investigations and Compliance Reviews
FMCSA overview of interventions, investigations, and compliance review context.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
FMCSA · agency-guide
New Entrant Safety Audit Resources
FMCSA New Entrant resource hub with safety audit, safety regulation, and program materials.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
FMCSA · agency-guide
Motor Carrier Safety Planner - Safety Ratings
FMCSA Safety Planner explanation of Satisfactory, Conditional, Unsatisfactory, and Unrated status.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
FMCSA · official
Safety Measurement System Help Center
FMCSA help center for SMS, safety ratings, and administrative review context.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
eCFR · regulation
49 CFR Part 391 - Qualifications of Drivers
Driver qualification rules, medical certification, applications, inquiries, and annual review context.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
eCFR · regulation
49 CFR Part 396 - Inspection, Repair, and Maintenance
Inspection, repair, maintenance, annual inspection, and roadside inspection records.
Last checked: 2026-06-16
eCFR · regulation
49 CFR Part 395 - Hours of Service of Drivers
Hours-of-service rules and supporting document requirements.
Last checked: 2026-06-16